What is NODE_ENV?

The NODE_ENV environment variable became popular early in Node.js development as a convention to distinguish between runtime environments like development, testing, and production. It is now widely used and supported across many tools and frameworks in the Node.js ecosystem, allowing developers to implement environment-specific configurations and optimizations.

Unfortunatley, many developers don’t grasp its purpose and use it incorrectly.

Countless projects incorrectly use the environment variable NODE_ENV to specify the name of their environment (like dev, stg, prd, etc.) but the purpose of NODE_ENV is to specify the type of the environment, not its name.
The expected values of NODE_ENV are development, test and production.

Various tools and libraries change their behaviour based on the value of NODE_ENV:

• when NODE_ENV is set to development, some tools may load additional code to show useful warnings, enable hot reloading and skip optimizations that are not necessary when you are developing the app;
• when NODE_ENV is set to test, you may want to instrument your code for code coverage;
• when NODE_ENV is set to production, certain tools may optimize code execution paths, eliminate unused code, and apply optimizations as needed to enhance performance.

How some popular Node applications and framworks handle NODE_ENV

• Node.js recommends to always set NODE_ENV to production; setting it to a different value and using the value of NODE_ENV to drive the application behaviour is considered an anti-pattern:

  • https://nodejs.org/en/learn/getting-started/nodejs-the-difference-between-development-and-production

• Various commands of Npm (install, update, prune, ci, etc. ) use the value of NODE_ENV to include or exclude the dev dependencies from processing:

  • https://docs.npmjs.com/cli/v8/commands/npm-install
  • https://docs.npmjs.com/cli/v9/commands/npm-update
  • https://docs.npmjs.com/cli/v9/commands/npm-prune
  • https://docs.npmjs.com/cli/v9/commands/npm-ci

• Yarn v1 uses it on yarn install to include or exclude the dev dependencies:

  • https://classic.yarnpkg.com/lang/en/docs/cli/install/

• It seems that Yarn v2+ does not use the NODE_ENV environment variable and drives its behaviour based only on the command line arguments.

• Next.js recommends to use only one of development, test or production as the value of NODE_ENV. A different value might cause dependencies to work unexpectedly.

  • https://nextjs.org/docs/messages/non-standard-node-env

• NestJS does not make any difference between development and production environments but recommends to use production when running the application in a production environment. It does not make any recommendation for other environments.

  • https://docs.nestjs.com/deployment#node_envproduction

• Jest sets NODE_ENV to test if it is not already set. Apparently, it does this so that the tested code can enable/disable logging, optimisations etc. when it runs in test mode. Jest itself does not change its behaviour based on the value of NODE_ENV.

  • https://jestjs.io/docs/environment-variables

• Setting NODE_ENV to production makes Express:

  • cache view templates;
  • cache CSS files generated from CSS extensions;
  • generate less verbose error messages.

  Source: https://expressjs.com/en/advanced/best-practice-performance.html#set-node_env-to-production

• React uses the terms development build and production build everywhere in its documentation. These are the differences between them:

  1. development build:

     • includes helpful warnings, error messages, and debugging tools such as source maps;
     • slower performance due to additional checks and verbose logging;
     • used during the development phase to aid debugging and testing.

  2. production build:

     • minified and optimized for performance by removing warnings and unnecessary code;
     • smaller file sizes, leading to faster load times and reduced bandwidth usage;
     • intended for deployment to end users.

  Although not officially documented, the two build modes are identified by checking the value of NODE_ENV against production or development.

How to use NODE_ENV in applications?

The applications should not know in what environment they run. The environment variables should be used to set the configuration values that vary across environments. When behaviour needs to differ across environments, the best way is to use the Strategy design pattern; implement the behaviour that varies in several components that implement the same interface and decide at runtime which of them to use based on the value of a configuration entry (provided as an environment variable). Use different values for the variable based on the environment (or environment type) where the application runs.

As an exception to the rule above, use the value of NODE_ENV in applications to implement optimisations (or skip some costly verifications) when the code run in production and provide better support for developers (in the development mode.)